Why I Hate “But They Love You”

I’ve heard it countless times:
“But they love you.”

Usually said right after something painful has been shared.
Something deeply hurtful.
Sometimes even abusive.

And every time I hear that sentence, something inside me tightens.

Because here’s the truth:
love doesn’t erase hurt.

Love doesn’t give someone a free pass to hurt you.
It doesn’t excuse manipulation, control, cruel words, broken promises, or repeated neglect.

When people say, “but they love you,” it often feels like they’re really saying,
“Your pain isn’t valid because they say they care.”

And that’s exhausting.

Because it ignores the reality that love and harm can exist in the same space.
And that the presence of love doesn’t cancel out the damage that comes with it.

Sometimes we have to separate the idea of love from the actions of the person claiming it.
And that’s hard.
It’s painful.
It can feel wrong to even question someone who says they care.

But here’s what I’ve learned:

You don’t have to accept harm because someone claims to love you.
You don’t have to justify your boundaries.
You don’t have to minimize your experience to make others comfortable.

Because love isn’t a shield for abuse…

Many Blessings, Grace. Xx

Pinterest | Instagram | Facebook | Tik Tok


Discover more from Grace Blakiston

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

42 responses to “Why I Hate “But They Love You””

  1. Love was never meant tear down but only to build up. The hard reality of love is that you have to love something so much that you have to say no to what must be loved less. If love is not devoted to loving someone more than you love yourself without seeking anything in return but believing they will be doing the same then true love has been found. We know the very best example of that from a God who proved it. Even He knows that love will ultimately mean no to something and someone. Be strong. Be true. Be loving.

    1. Amen! Thankful for a Heavenly Father who represents true… and real love, fully and beautifully. 🥹

  2. Thank you, as always, for these insights Grace. God bless.

    1. Thank you for reading. 🤍

  3. LOVE IS BEAUTIFUL BUT DEFINITELY SHOULD NOT HURT!!

    1. Love is beautiful but true love requires a willing sacrifice which may not always appear beautiful in the moment but become precious when truly understood. Who can look at the cross (not the sanitized one we can comfortably observe) and think beautiful knowing the horror story of it but remember precious when considering the result of grace over our lives it rendered because the love for us which demanded sacrifice laid down His life that we might live with God forever.

      1. Amen! Love really does require sacrifice on all ends! ❤️

    2. Yes, certainly not in this way. ❤️‍🩹

  4. Well said. Thank you for making this helpful distinction.

    1. 🫶🏾🫶🏾🫶🏾

  5. So true. Thank you for sharing.

    1. Thank you for reading! Xx

  6. thnks for sharing. God Bless.

    1. Many blessings to you too! 💛

  7. Well said, Grace. True love doesn’t treat others this way.

  8. God is love… praying for you, little sister…

    1. Thank you! 🙏

  9. Great perspective, Grace. Thanks for sharing.

  10. Beautiful and so true , thanks for writing this 👏🏼

    1. Thanks for reading. 🥰

  11. This is so true Grace. Thanks for sharing.

    1. Thank you! And thank you for reading. 💛

  12. Absolutely. There is a world of difference between forgiveness and reconciliation.

    There is also a biblical proverb about someone shooting arrows randomly without care, and then saying that they were only joking: With regard to your point about that not being okay.

    Thank you for your post.

    1. Amen! Thank you for sharing that scripture here too. 🫶🏾

      1. Sure, thanks <3

  13. Thank you for liking my article. Your writing is heartfelt and reclaiming your power showing yourself the true meaning of love.

    1. Aw, thank you so much for your kind words. 🥹

  14. I agree. Some narcissistic individuals do cover their abuse and say that they are doing what they are doing out of love. They also convince others that they are loving, and these people tell you that they love you and invalidate your hurt by doing so. The Bible says that love is not selfish or seeks to hurt others. So, do they really love or are they self- seeking? That is the question we must ask.

    1. So true! Thanks for sharing your thoughts too. 🧡

  15. currently feeling this heavily, thank you for sharing beloved sis <333

    1. Of course! Praying peace over you. ❤️

      1. likewise beloved sister 🙏✨🌌🌀

  16. This post is a God-send for me at this very moment.

    1. Praying peace over your life. 💜

  17. I hear you and this post resonates with me, that is why I quote you.

    “Because here’s the truth:
    love doesn’t erase hurt.
    It doesn’t excuse manipulation, control, cruel words, broken promises, or repeated neglect.”

    Some days I say to myself, what’s the use. But I know my purpose here is already mapped out. I just need to stand firm and don’t disappoint God.

    1. Yes, there’s definitely a fine line between turning the other cheek and having healthy biblical boundaries when it comes to all types of relationships. ❤️

  18. This!!! 1000 times this. 🙌🏻

    1. For real!! 😭

Leave a Reply

Discover more from Grace Blakiston

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading